Tankless vs Tank Water Heater: Which is Right for Your Portsmouth Home?

If you're in need of a water heater replacement, you might find yourself stuck between choosing a tankless or a traditional tank water heater. Both options have their pros and cons, but it ultimately comes down to your specific needs and preferences. We'll explain both types in our comprehensive guide, considering factors like cost-effectiveness, maintenance, installation, and how long they last. With this knowledge, you'll be able to make a smart decision. If you need more help, just ask!

What is a storage tank water heater and how it works?

A storage tank water heater is a common type of water heating system found in many homes. It works by storing and heating a certain amount of water in a tank until it is needed for use. When hot water is turned on, the water from the tank is drawn into the pipes and delivered to the faucet or shower. Inside the storage tank, there are heating elements, usually powered by electricity or gas, that warm the water to a desired temperature. This temperature is typically controlled by a thermostat. When the hot water is used, cold water enters the tank to replace the water that was used. The heating elements then heat the new cold water, maintaining a constant supply of hot water in the tank. Storage tank water heaters come in various sizes, ranging from small units that can hold around 20 gallons of water, to larger units that can hold up to 80 gallons or more. The size of the tank depends on the household's hot water needs and the number of people living in the home.

Benefits of a tank water heater

When it comes to heating the water in your home, there are several options available, one of which is a tank water heater. While tankless water heaters are gaining popularity, there are still many benefits to choosing a tank water heater for your home.

  • Cost-effectiveness: Tank water heaters are generally more affordable than tankless water heaters. Not only are they cheaper to purchase, but they also have lower installation costs. If you're on a budget, a tank water heater may be the better option for you.

  • Simplicity: Tank water heaters are straightforward and easy to use. They feature a storage tank of hot water that is constantly heated and ready for use. This means there is no waiting for the water to heat up, ensuring a steady supply of hot water whenever you need it.

  • Reliability: Tank water heaters are known for their reliability. They have been used in homes for decades and have a proven track record of performance. With proper maintenance, a tank water heater can last for many years, providing hot water consistently.

  • Easy Replacement: If your tank water heater breaks down, it can be easily replaced. Since these heaters are commonly used, finding a replacement unit is usually not a problem. This means you don't have to worry about extensive downtime or the inconvenience of not having hot water.

  • Compatibility: Tank water heaters are compatible with most homes, regardless of the plumbing setup. They can be installed in both old and new constructions, making them a versatile choice for homeowners.

  • Energy Efficiency: While tankless water heaters are generally more energy-efficient, tank water heaters have made significant improvements in recent years. Many models come with smart features that help reduce energy consumption. Additionally, proper insulation can help minimize heat loss, saving you money on your energy bills.

What are the drawbacks of a tank water heater?

A tank water heater, like any appliance, does have its drawbacks. Understanding these drawbacks can help you make an informed decision when considering a water heater replacement:

  • One of the main drawbacks of a tank water heater is its limited capacity. These heaters typically have a predetermined size and can only hold a certain amount of hot water at a time. If you have a large household with multiple bathrooms or use hot water for various tasks simultaneously, you may find yourself running out of hot water quickly.

  • Tank water heaters have a longer recovery time. Once the hot water is used up, it takes time for the tank to refill and heat the water back to the desired temperature. This can be an inconvenience if you need hot water urgently or if multiple people in your household need to take showers consecutively.

  • Another drawback to consider is energy inefficiency. Tank water heaters continuously heat and store water, even when it's not in use. This constant heating can result in energy wastage and higher utility bills. On the other hand, tankless water heaters heat the water on-demand, providing more energy efficiency and potentially saving you money in the long run.

  • Tank water heaters have a limited lifespan. Depending on factors such as usage, maintenance, and water quality, these heaters typically last around 10-15 years. As they age, they may become less efficient and more prone to leaks, requiring costly repairs or a full water heater replacement.

What is a tankless water heater and how does it work?

A tankless water heater is a modern and efficient alternative to traditional water heaters. Unlike conventional water heaters that store and heat a large amount of water in a tank, tankless water heaters heat water on demand as it flows through the unit. This means that there is no need for a large storage tank, which can take up valuable space in your home. Tankless water heaters work by using high-powered burners to rapidly heat the water as it passes through a heat exchanger. When a hot water tap is turned on, cold water enters the unit and is quickly heated to the desired temperature. This instant heating process eliminates the need for a storage tank and allows for an endless supply of hot water.

What are the benefits of a tankless water heater?

Tankless water heaters offer a plethora of benefits compared to traditional tank-style water heaters. In this article, we will explore some of the advantages of installing a tankless water heater in your home.

  • Energy Efficiency: One of the key benefits of a tankless water heater is its energy efficiency. Unlike traditional water heaters that constantly heat and store a large amount of water, tankless water heaters only heat water on demand. This means that they do not waste energy by continuously heating water that is not being used. As a result, tankless water heaters can help you save on your monthly energy bills.

  • Endless Hot Water: With a tankless water heater, you no longer have to worry about running out of hot water. These units provide hot water on demand, allowing you to enjoy endless showers, run multiple appliances simultaneously, and meet the hot water needs of your entire household. Whether you have a large family or enjoy long hot showers, a tankless water heater can provide a continuous supply of hot water.

  • Space Saving: Tankless water heaters are significantly smaller than traditional tank-style water heaters. They can be mounted on a wall or installed in a compact, out-of-the-way location, freeing up valuable floor space in your home. This can be particularly beneficial if you have a small utility room or are looking to maximize space efficiency.

  • Longer Lifespan: Tankless water heaters typically have a longer lifespan compared to traditional water heaters. While tank-style water heaters may last around 10-15 years, tankless units can last up to 20 years or more with proper maintenance. Investing in a tankless water heater can potentially save you money in the long run, as you will not have to replace it as often.

  • Reduced Risk of Water Damage: Traditional tank-style water heaters are at risk of leaking or bursting, potentially causing significant water damage to your home. Tankless water heaters, on the other hand, eliminate this risk as there is no large tank of water that could potentially leak. This can give you peace of mind, knowing that you are not at risk of sudden water damage.

What are the disadvantages of a tankless water heater?

There are also some disadvantages to consider before investing in a tankless water heater:

  • One of the main disadvantages of a tankless water heater is the upfront cost. Tankless water heaters tend to be more expensive than traditional tank-style heaters.

  • They require complex installation, which can be more time-consuming and costly. If your home is not already equipped with the necessary electrical or gas infrastructure, the installation costs could further increase.

  • Another disadvantage of tankless water heaters is their limited flow rate. While tankless heaters can provide a continuous supply of hot water, they have a maximum flow rate. This means that if multiple appliances or faucets are running simultaneously, the water heater may struggle to keep up with the high demand. This can result in a decrease in water pressure or a temperature fluctuation.

  • Maintenance and servicing can also be a drawback of tankless water heaters. Traditional tank-style water heaters require annual maintenance, such as flushing out sediments and checking for leaks. However, tankless heaters may need more frequent maintenance, especially if you live in an area with hard water. Mineral buildup can affect the performance and efficiency of the unit, requiring regular descaling or flushing.

  • Depending on your location and the model of the tankless water heater, there may be a delay in getting hot water. Unlike tank-style heaters, which store hot water, tankless heaters heat water on-demand. This means that there may be a brief delay between turning on the faucet and getting hot water.

Are storage tank water heaters energy-efficient?

Traditional models with storage tanks have a long-standing reputation for their energy consumption. These water heaters tirelessly heat water, even when it's not being used, making them less energy-efficient. However, advancements in technology have led to the development of newer tank models that offer increased energy savings. One of the key improvements in these newer tank models lies in their insulation and heating features. With enhanced insulation, these water heaters are better able to retain heat, reducing the energy needed to maintain the desired temperature. Additionally, the heating elements in these models have been optimized for performance, allowing for more efficient and faster heating. It is worth noting that while these newer tank models offer improved energy efficiency, they may not be the most environmentally friendly option. As they still rely on electricity or gas to operate, they generate emissions that contribute to environmental pollution. However, for many households, these tank models remain a reliable and practical choice.

Are tankless water heaters energy-efficient?

Tankless water heaters are known for their energy efficiency. Unlike traditional water heaters, which constantly store and heat a large amount of water in a tank, tankless water heaters heat water on-demand as it flows through the unit. This means that they only consume energy when hot water is needed, thus eliminating the standby energy losses associated with traditional water heaters. The energy efficiency of tankless water heaters stems from their ability to provide hot water instantly and in an endless supply. Since there is no need to store and continuously heat a large volume of water, tankless water heaters can help homeowners save energy and reduce their utility bills. In fact, according to the U.S. Department of Energy, switching from a traditional water heater to a tankless unit can result in energy savings of up to 30%.

Cost to buy and install

a tank water heater

On average, tank water heaters can range from $500 to $2,000. However, if you're interested in a more advanced model with additional features, the price can be higher. Keep in mind that installation costs can also add to the overall expense, potentially reaching up to $1,500. The final cost of installation depends on local labor rates and the existing plumbing conditions in your home. Before installing a new water heater, it's important to consider a few factors. Firstly, make sure your home has a dedicated electrical circuit and a reliable gas line to support the new unit. These requirements ensure that your water heater can operate efficiently and safely. Another crucial consideration is selecting a tank size that matches the hot water needs of your household. This is essential for providing an adequate supply of hot water to everyone in your home. Taking into account the number of people living in your household and their typical usage patterns can help you determine the right tank size.

Cost to buy and install

a tankless water heater

Tankless water heaters typically range in price from $1,000 to over $3,000. The installation costs can vary between $500 to $2,000, depending on factors like your home's plumbing system and local labor rates. Unlike traditional water heaters, tankless units operate without a storage tank, making them more compact and efficient. However, it's important to ensure that your home's infrastructure can handle the higher energy demand of a tankless system. These units require a larger gas line and an electricity source. Consulting with a professional installer is vital to determine if your home meets the requirements for a tankless water heater. Choosing the appropriate unit size is also crucial for optimal performance. Consider your household's hot water needs to select the right tankless water heater that can meet your demands. A professional installer can help you identify the suitable unit size based on the number of bathrooms, appliances, and faucets in your home. Although tankless water heaters may be more expensive upfront, their energy-saving features can save you money in the long run. Not only do they provide an endless supply of hot water, but they also have a longer lifespan compared to traditional models. With proper maintenance and care, a tankless water heater can last up to 20 years or more.

Common storage tank water heater maintenance issues

If you have a storage tank water heater, there are some common maintenance issues that you may encounter. It's important to address these issues promptly to ensure that your water heater is functioning efficiently and to avoid any potential problems. Here are a few common maintenance issues to be aware of:

  • Sediment buildup: Over time, sediment can accumulate at the bottom of the storage tank, especially if you have hard water. This sediment can affect the water heater's efficiency and lead to decreased hot water output. To prevent this, it's recommended to flush your water heater regularly to remove the sediment buildup.

  • Leaks: Leaks can occur in various parts of the water heater, such as the tank or the pressure relief valve. If you notice water pooling around your water heater or any signs of water damage, it's important to address the issue immediately. Leaks can not only lead to water wastage but can also cause damage to your property if left untreated.

  • Corrosion: Corrosion is a common issue in storage tank water heaters, especially if they are not properly maintained. Corrosion can weaken the tank, leading to leaks or even complete failure. Regular inspection of your water heater for any signs of corrosion, such as rust or discoloration, is essential. If you notice any corrosion, it's best to have the tank replaced to avoid any further issues.

  • Inefficient heating: If your water heater is not providing sufficient hot water or if it takes a long time to heat up, there may be an issue with the heating element or thermostat. These components can wear out over time and may need to be replaced. Regular checks and maintenance of these parts can help prevent any unexpected issues.

Common tankless water heater maintenance issues

While tankless water heaters are designed to require less maintenance than traditional tank-based water heaters, there are still some common issues that may arise and require attention:

  • One common maintenance issue with tankless water heaters is mineral buildup. Over time, minerals such as calcium and magnesium can accumulate inside the heating elements and pipes of the unit. This can lead to reduced water flow and decreased performance. To prevent this issue, it is recommended to flush the tankless water heater regularly, following the manufacturer's instructions. Flushing will help remove any mineral buildup and keep your system running smoothly.

  • Another common issue is improper venting. Tankless water heaters require proper ventilation to expel combustion gases safely. If the venting is not installed correctly or becomes blocked, it can lead to serious safety hazards, such as carbon monoxide buildup. It is crucial to have a professional install and inspect the venting system to ensure it meets local building codes and operates safely.

  • A third maintenance issue is a failing heat exchanger. The heat exchanger is a critical component that transfers heat from the burners to the water. Over time, corrosion or scale buildup can occur, negatively affecting the heat transfer process. If you notice a decrease in hot water output or inconsistent temperatures, it may indicate a failing heat exchanger. In such cases, it is recommended to contact a professional technician to inspect and potentially replace the heat exchanger.

  • Tankless water heaters may experience issues with water pressure. Insufficient water pressure can reduce the unit's performance and lead to inadequate hot water supply. The problem could be due to clogged filters, water line issues, or a faulty pressure relief valve. Regularly checking and cleaning the filters, inspecting the water lines, and ensuring the pressure relief valve is functioning correctly can help address water pressure problems.

What is the lifespan of a tank water heater?

When it comes to tank water heaters, one of the most frequently asked questions is, "What is the lifespan of a tank water heater?" This is an important question to consider if you're a homeowner looking to determine when you may need a water heater replacement. The average lifespan of a tank water heater is typically around 8 to 12 years. However, this can vary depending on several factors including the quality of the water heater, maintenance, and usage frequency. Higher quality water heaters that are well-maintained and not subjected to excessive wear and tear may last closer to 10 to 12 years, while lower quality units or those that are not properly maintained may need to be replaced after only 8 years or even sooner. It's important to note that as a water heater ages, its efficiency may decrease. This can result in higher energy bills or issues with providing a consistent supply of hot water. If you notice any signs of deterioration, such as leaks, rust, or a decline in performance, it may be time to start considering a water heater replacement. If you notice any of these signs, it is important to contact a professional to assess the situation.

What is the lifespan

of a tankless water heater?

You can expect tankless water heaters to last around 20 years or even longer with proper maintenance. This is significantly longer compared to traditional tank water heaters, which typically have a lifespan of around 10 to 15 years. The longevity of tankless water heaters can be attributed to their design and construction. Unlike tank water heaters that store and constantly heat a large amount of water, tankless water heaters heat water on demand as it flows through the unit. This eliminates the need for a storage tank and reduces the risk of corrosion and other issues associated with storing water. Additionally, tankless water heaters are typically made with high-quality materials that can withstand the heat and pressure generated during operation. Regular maintenance, such as descaling to remove mineral buildup, can further extend the lifespan of your tankless water heater. It's important to note that the lifespan of a tankless water heater can vary depending on factors such as water quality, usage patterns, and maintenance. Hard water, for example, can cause mineral buildup and reduce the efficiency of the unit over time. To ensure optimal performance and longevity, it's recommended to consult the manufacturer's guidelines and schedule annual maintenance by a professional technician.

Gas vs electric water heaters

Portsmouth homeowners often face the decision of choosing between gas vs electric water heaters. Both options have their own advantages and considerations to take into account. Gas water heaters use natural gas or propane to heat the water. They tend to be more energy-efficient, offering cost savings over time. Gas water heaters can provide hot water even during power outages, which can be a benefit in areas prone to electricity disruptions. Additionally, gas water heaters typically have a faster recovery rate, meaning they can replenish hot water more quickly. On the other hand, electric water heaters run solely on electricity. They have a higher upfront cost compared to gas water heaters, but their installation tends to be easier. Electric water heaters are considered more eco-friendly as they produce zero emissions. They also offer the flexibility of being installed in various locations, as they do not require any venting. When deciding between a gas and electric water heater replacement, it is essential to consider the fuel availability and cost in your area. If you have access to affordable natural gas or propane, a gas water heater could be a more cost-effective option in the long run. However, if electricity is more readily available and cost-efficient in your area, an electric water heater might be a better choice.

How to decide if a tankless or a tank water heater

is right for you

If you're in the market for a new water heater, one of the first decisions you'll need to make is whether to go with a tankless or a tank water heater. Both options have their advantages and disadvantages, so it's important to consider your specific needs and preferences before making a decision.

  • Tankless water heaters, as the name suggests, heat water on demand rather than storing it in a tank. This means that you'll never run out of hot water, since it's heated as you need it.

  • Tankless water heaters are also more energy efficient than tank water heaters, as they only heat water when it's needed. This can result in significant savings on your energy bills over time.

  • On the other hand, tank water heaters store a large amount of hot water in a tank, ready to be used whenever you need it. While this means that you may need to wait for the tank to refill and reheat after it runs out, tank water heaters tend to have a higher hot water flow rate and are often less expensive to purchase and install than tankless water heaters.

  • Think about your hot water needs. Do you have a large family with multiple people showering and using hot water simultaneously? If so, a tank water heater with its higher flow rate may be the best choice for you. If you live alone or with a smaller household and prioritize energy efficiency, a tankless water heater may be a better fit.

  • Next, consider your budget. Tankless water heaters tend to have a higher upfront cost than tank water heaters, but their energy efficiency can lead to long-term savings on your utility bills. If you're willing to invest more upfront for potential energy savings down the line, a tankless water heater may be worth it.

  • Think about your overall home energy usage. If you're already conscious of your energy consumption and have taken steps to reduce it, a tankless water heater may align with your sustainability goals. However, if you're not as concerned about energy efficiency, a tank water heater may be a more cost-effective choice.

Is it important to hire a licensed professional?

Hiring a licensed professional is of utmost importance. Although it may be tempting to attempt the replacement yourself or hire someone without proper credentials to save money, the potential risks and hazards associated with this task make it essential to choose a licensed professional. Licensed professionals have undergone rigorous training and certification processes to ensure they have the necessary knowledge and expertise to handle water heater replacement safely and effectively. They are well-versed in building codes and regulations, ensuring that the installation is done in compliance with the law. This can give you peace of mind, knowing that your water heater replacement is being handled by someone who understands the importance of safety and adherence to regulations. Moreover, hiring a licensed professional minimizes the risk of damage to your property. Water heaters are complex systems, and one small mistake during installation can lead to leaks, flooding, or even electrical issues. A licensed professional will have the necessary skills and experience to complete the replacement without causing any damage to your home. Additionally, hiring a licensed professional can save you money in the long run. While their services may come at a higher initial cost compared to an unlicensed individual, their expertise and quality workmanship mean that you are less likely to encounter issues or breakdowns in the future. A properly installed water heater can operate efficiently, reducing energy consumption and saving you money on utility bills.

Researching tankless vs tank water heaters

is important

If you're in need of a water heater replacement, there are a few key things to consider before making your decision. The first choice you'll face is whether to go with a traditional tank model or a tankless option. To help you make an informed decision, it's important to evaluate your specific requirements, budget, and installation needs. Choosing the right water heater is crucial because it can have a significant impact on your home. Not only can it reduce energy costs, but it can also ensure you have a reliable and consistent supply of hot water whenever you need it. To make the best choice, take the time to thoroughly research and evaluate different types of units, including their energy efficiency ratings. By doing your due diligence and considering these factors, you'll be better equipped to select the water heater that is best suited for your home. Good luck in your decision-making process!

Contact Us

One of the most significant investments you can make in your home is a water heater replacement.


PHONE:+(757) 379-8344

Newman's Plumbing Service and Repair

Portsmouth, VA 23701